First thing’s first: I can’t include Bob Dylan in this list. Yes, he was born in Duluth, MN, and grew up in Hibbing. Yes, he spent a year or two putzing around Dinkytown (the “bohemian”/college campus part of Minneapolis), but everybody knows he really cut his teeth and became the fuzzy-headed, Mad-lib lyrics legend that he is in New York City. So here’s the deal: I won’t include Bob Dylan in my “The 15 Greatest Twin Cities Bands/Musicians of All Time” list, but that means I get to pretend like Semisonic never existed. Deal? Okay.
Now, there’s a lot of great/interesting/important bands that didn’t make my list, like Halo Of Flies, Har Mar Superstar, Off With Their Heads, Harvest, The Castaways, The Suburbs, The Litter and much more. That just goes to show how storied the Minneapolis/St. Paul history is. Feel free to leave a comment if you think a band should have been included. And, like Dylan, there’s bands like Low, Trampled By Turtles and the Gear Daddies that are commonly referred to as Twin Cities bands but are actually from Duluth and Austin, respectively. No list for them!
Oh and guess who else isn’t on this list? Howler. Those guys suck in any town.
So, without further ado, my list (with YouTube videos in the links) of the 15 Greatest Twin Cities Bands/Musicians of All Time:
15) Mark Mallman – I honestly never liked Mark’s music until I saw him live at 7th Street Entry. He bopped around with his boppity hair at a keyboard and directed every band member like an orchestra conductor. He wore ridiculously hideous studded denim jackets. He was hilarious. A fan was born. What a weirdo.
14) The Soviettes – I love the Soviettes! Girl punk at it’s best. And the drummer kind of sounds like the dude from the B-52s, somehow. Ironically, I cannot stand their side-project band Awesome Snakes. Rock lobster!
13) Quincy Punx – This band did not give a FUCK. I mean that in the best way possible.
12) Cows – Cows were the best example of that weird, noisey, AmRep sound that ran parallel to grunge in the 90s, but didn’t get 5% of the attention. If these guys aren’t in an insane asylum today, I don’t know where they’d be.
11) The Trashmen – These guys really only had one hit song back in 1963, “Surfin’ Bird.” Yeah, it’s basically two Rivington’s songs mashed together. But they made it SO much better. And it’s also arguably the first punk rock song ever. I never fully appreciated this song until I heard it blasted at ear-bleeding volume at a bar in Madison. It shook my guts like a paint-mixer. And I’ve never seen the episode, but apparently Family Guy used this song in one of it’s shows and a bunch of morons think it’s from that. Sit down, son. This is the best fake surf band that Minnesota ever produced.
10) Morris Day & The Time – It’s impossible to mention The Time without Prince. They were his cronies and underlies. They were the Scottie Pippen to Prince’s Michael Jordan. Gilligan to Prince’s Skipper. St. Paul to Prince’s Minneapolis. But damn, they sure sounded good. I also feel like MC Scat Kat is more real than these cartoon characters.
9) The Suicide Commandos – Formed in 1975, the Commandos were the Twin Cities’ first punk rock band. They also appeared to be about 3 feet tall and could have played Richard Dreyfuss’ part in Jaws.
8) Atmosphere – I’m a little tired of Minneapolis rap. Brother Ali, P.O.S., Doomtree. It’s all a bit slam-poety for me. But Atmosphere has enough melody to their music and they change it up pretty frequently, so I’m a fan. “Now I’m too fucked up to dance, so I’ma sit with my hand on the front of my pants.”
7) Lifter Puller – The pre-Hold Steady. I would have put Lifter Puller higher, but I’m friends with the guitar player, Steve Barone, on Facebook and I don’t want to look like I’m kissing his ass. Craig Finn takes Twin Cities name-dropping to exquisitely new heights.
6) Babes In Toyland – Just click on the link. If you don’t think this kicks ass, then you should just stop reading my blog. By the way, Courtney Love stole the dress from HER.
5) Dillinger Four – Paddy tends bar in several places across town. I’ve never gotten the nerve to ask him when the next D4 album is coming out. Seriously guys, Social Distortion kicks out albums faster than you guys. One of the best live bands you’ll ever see. If they’re not too drunk to hit the strings on their guitars.
4) Soul Asylum – It’s easier to convince people Big Foot is real than to convince people that Soul Asylum used to be good. From their early punk records to the pre-Runaway Train alternative rock stuff, give it a chance.
3) Husker Du – The Lennon/McCartney songwriting duo of the Twin Cities. They broke up four years before grunge went big. But they influenced the Pixies, who influenced Nirvana and blah blah blah. You know the story. Let’s be honest, they were too tubby and dorky to make it big, but they kick the shit out of those other bands any day.
3) Jay-Z – Just kidding.
2) The Replacements – Legendary. They either put on the most transcendentally amazing live shows or they’d get wasted and play “Hello Dolly” eight times in a row. They once supposedly played a showcase show full of half punk fans and half country fans. They played country until all the punks left, played punk until all the country dudes left and then yelled “Are we signed yet?!” When their record company pushed them to put out a music video for MTV, they returned with a video of a speaker blaring for four minutes, followed by five seconds of someone kicking the shit out of it. The Replacements are GODS.
1) Prince – Duh.